A Ghost
Story? [Mild SPOILERS]
For the last
week or so I've been working my way through the BFI DVD box-set 'Ghost Stories
for Christmas Expanded Six-Disk Collection' and trying to surmise my feelings
on the individual films contained therein.
Some of the films - such as Lost Hearts (1973), The Treasure of Abbot
Thomas (1974) and The Signalman (1976), to say nothing of the markedly more
recent 2010 remake of Whistle and I'll Come to You - are genuinely remarkable,
while other films are no more than enigmatic sketches that survive on sheer
atmosphere alone. Stigma (1977), the
last film to be directed by series regular Lawrence Gordon Clark, falls firmly
into the latter category, but is worth discussing for a few rather interesting thematic
and directorial ideas.
Right away
the first image of the film captured my imagination. A small red dot, like an orb or a distant
planet, is framed against an obscured landscape evocative of some vague
science-fiction themed setting, but also suggesting something of a similar atmosphere
to director Michelangelo Antonioni's psychological-drama, Red Desert (1964),
where the world of the film was frequently reduced to a clouded, indistinguishable
smear.
Stigma [Lawrence
Gordon Clark, 1977]:
As the
credits begin to form - superimposed as they are over this peculiar, abstract vista
- I started to question what this image could possibly imply. At first I thought it was the glow of a synthetic
sun, burning a hole through the image and searing the surface of the lens as if
an actual shaft of light had somehow pierced the retina of its artificial eye
and damaged it beyond repair. Then I
started to think of the more obvious connotation; the drop of blood and with it
the memory of an image seen in Nicolas Roeg's horror masterpiece Don't Look Now
(1973), where the smearing of a photograph in the opening scene became a premonition
to a later moment of blood-curdling threat.
Don't Look
Now [Nicolas Roeg, 1973]:
In a quite
brilliant directorial stroke, Clark has his cameraman, John Turner, rack the focus of the lens and suddenly the red
glowing orb is revealed to have been the out-of-focus glare of a red Citroën
Dyane 6; driven here by the film's protagonist, Katherine Delgado, and her
teenage daughter, Verity.
Stigma [Lawrence
Gordon Clark, 1977]:
The car
moves through the quiet countryside, surrounded, on both embankments, by fields
and woodland areas, and by the occasional appearance of the mysterious menhirs that
(in part) define the pastoral landscapes of Avebury, where the film takes
place.
In the
setting (and in the contrast between the very practical iconography) Clark is already
establishing a disparity between the old and the new; between the "ancient"
- as illustrated by the landscape and its mythical stone circles, and the near-unique,
almost elemental formation of the hills and fields - and the "modern"
- as clearly defined by the car and its cargo.
This juxtaposition is an important theme that gives some credibility to
the eventual development of the narrative; where the later sequences (following
the couple's return to the family cottage) seem to suggest an element of
reincarnation or possibly even demonic possession.
Stigma [Lawrence
Gordon Clark, 1977]:
N.B. Note the reappearance of the colour red as
seen on the cottage door.
Making their
way up from the driveway and into the back garden, the characters find two
local labourers hard at work attempting to remove a large stone from the surface
of the lawn. A short exchange of
dialogue sets-up their intentions and why this particular course of action has
been decided, despite the difficulty of the task at hand. Here, Clark deliberately contrasts the harsh,
mechanical appearance of the heavy-lifting machinery against the surrounding
environment, including those aforementioned stone formations that seem to
watch, ominously; like silent sentinels, or the agents of some primitive God.
Stigma [Lawrence
Gordon Clark, 1977]:
It is this
attempt to move the stone that seems to unleash the unseen evil that will soon
throw the lives of these characters (and the narrative itself) into disarray;
the generic practicalities of this recalling the recognisable tropes of horror
and science-fiction standards like Quatermass and the Pit (1967), The Stone
Tape (1972) and later films, like The Keep (1983), Prince of Darkness (1987)
and The Hole (2009), where man - in his infinite quest for knowledge or
cultural progression - inadvertently awakens something primitive, even
primordial, otherwise hidden beneath the earth.
Almost
immediately, the mother seems to become transfixed, as if caught in the spell
of some insidious "outsider" influence, which leaves her dispossessed
(no longer in control of her own emotions).
As she heads back into the house it's almost as if she's drifting
through her own life; a sleepwalker, acting but not reacting, or like a puppet
compelled into action by the command of a secret master.
As if to
create a natural association to where the narrative will eventually lead us,
Clark signals the moment before the character's metaphysical metamorphosis with
a shot that has some relevance to an earlier film of his own direction. Here, the claw-like hook of the digger and
the very specific way in which it seems to hang in judgement over the face of
the character (and the act of desecration that she's brought to bear) looks
just like a noose. A noose, which - in
the dark days of people like Mathew Hopkins, the "Witchfinder
General" - might have sent a generation of young women like Katherine to
their deaths.
Stigma [Lawrence
Gordon Clark, 1977]:
This
suggestion of judgement or persecution from beyond the grave seems
intentionally designed to evoke the same territory as Clark's earlier film from
the same series, The Ash Tree (1975). There,
a woman accused and subsequently hanged for the crime of heresy exacts revenge
on her prosecutors in a manner best befitting the supernatural predilections of
the story's author, M.R. James.
The Ash Tree
[Lawrence Gordon Clark, 1975]:
Throughout
the film Clark offers these potential clues to understanding or at least
interpreting the film's strange and often intangible plot; these bizarre, enigmatic
images, or moments that seem to push the audience towards a particular reading (or
justification) for the increasingly strange goings-on. Subtle clues that the audience need to read
seem unclear or even arbitrary at the time, but make a small modicum of sense
when we see them against the eventual revelation of what this "evil" actually
is and of the dark place from which it seems to have emerged.
One such
link that Clark and the writer Clive Exton seem to construct is created by
intercutting the very frightening and disturbing dilemma of the mother with
scenes of her daughter doing ordinary things that become somewhat strange (or
extraordinary) when placed within the wider context of later events.
A shot of Verity
sat cross-legged on the bedroom floor and illuminated by a small lamp that's
been placed like a crystal ball amidst the chaos of teenage debris would not
look out of place in a film about troubled youth or family dysfunction, but now
seems to evoke the mystical, as the mother suddenly begins to act out of
character, as if haunted, or again, genuinely possessed...
Stigma [Lawrence
Gordon Clark, 1977]:
Red again,
this time as polish on the daughter's finger nails.
Here, the
child, removed from events, but almost in contemplation of them, tenses her
red-painted fingertips, prayer-like, in a near-magisterial expression; like a witch
presiding over a cauldron manifestation taking place in the adjacent room.
Several
clues to potentially understanding the film can be found in this scene. First, there is the song on the soundtrack;
Mother's Little Helper by the Rolling Stones.
The song underlines the significance of the mother/daughter
relationship, illustrated here by the spatial and/or emotional separation of
Katherine and Verity. The bond between
mother and daughter is supposed to be a strong one, but while Katherine goes
through her own private anguish in the family bathroom, or wanders disconnected
around the kitchen in an empty daze, Verity seems oblivious; instead, heading
to the local shop or sitting pensive by the lamplight; spinning her disks with
an almost inhuman indifference. This
creates a number of questions that again will make a greater sense towards the
end of the film, but for the most part seem to be beyond any standard
comprehension.
Even the
name of the band on the soundtrack is a kind of clue. The "Rolling Stones", creating an
associative link to the ancient stones that now surround the small house and
imprison its inhabitants, while further black magic intrigues are hinted at by
the somewhat obvious placement of the band's 1966 album, Their Satanic
Majesties Request, amongst the disorganisation of Verity's bedroom.
There is
also that interesting use of intercutting, which at first seems frustrating,
since it appears to disrupt our connection with Katherine and the terrifying
reality of her situation, but which in hindsight gives meaning to the
perspective of Verity and the very primal connection that she seems to have to
these ancient stone markings that define the surrounding environment and the
world outside the home.
Stigma [Lawrence
Gordon Clark, 1977]:
Cross-cutting
interior and exterior spaces (the physical and
the psychological/natural and
supernatural, etc)
The
intercutting of the two locations seems designed to bring these elements
together. On the one hand, we have the scenes
of teenage alienation; the daughter, unable to connect with mum, wanders the
fields and hills and finds comfort in her room and in the isolation of it. On the other hand, we have a very violent and
unsettling horror story that seems to cut back and forth between the
supernatural and the psychological, as the audience, for the most part at
least, remains unsure of the real cause of Katherine's unfortunate malady.
It is in the
juxtaposition of scenes and the individual arcs of the narrative that Clark offers
some reason for events; allowing the viewer to make a connection between the
elements so far seen and to use what we know of the horror movie, as a genre,
to fill in the blanks. The implication,
that this mythical landscape and the stone formations that so transfix the
alienated Verity are somehow conspiring with the ghost of a long-dead victim to
take revenge on those unfortunate enough to disturb their unholy slumber, seems
to be further reinforced by the development of subsequent scenes.
Stigma [Lawrence
Gordon Clark, 1977]:
Henry
Fuseli's painting, The Nightmare (1781).
A hint that things are happening outside the realms
of reality, or simply an
acknowledgement of some other form of bodily possession?
By
connecting the various occurrences - with one scene leading into another scene,
like the links in a chain - Clark and Exton give the audience just enough
possibilities to create their own hypothesis regarding the fate of these
characters. In reality, there is no
rational explanation for anything taking place, but by seeing an image of
Katherine acting dazed and trancelike against an image of the stones as seen through
the kitchen window, or the shot of Verity in her bedroom intercut with the
mother's violent ordeal, we create a connection between the two. It's like the Kuleshov Effect in narrative
form, wherein the intercutting of potentially unrelated sequences forces the
audience to make an associative connection; in a sense, creating the story
themselves.
This idea
brings us back to that strange and ominous orb seen drifting during the opening
credits. There, the glare of the family
car as an out of focus blot against an abstract landscape took on the
appearance of an almost extra-terrestrial vision. However, when we think back to this sequence
with the subsequent knowledge of the situation taking place, that connection to
the drop of blood (and the idea of the blood as an objective premonition) seems
explicitly linked to the horror that befalls the central character.
Having been
possessed (seemingly) by a ghost, or by the spirit of the landscape itself,
Katherine is struck by an especially terrifying physical affliction. Blood seeping through the skin, as if secreting
from an internal wound that doesn't seem to exist, at least not in the corporal
sense. The way the red dot grows in
intensity, spreading out as it soaks through the fabric of Katherine's shirt,
once again reminded me of the first image of the film and that red-hued
harbinger that appeared to overwhelm the screen.
Stigma [Lawrence
Gordon Clark, 1977]:
It is this
literal translation of the title - the "stigma" as short for stigmata,
in the biblical sense (although the cause of this bloodletting seems to point to something that runs counter to the
Christian myth) - which seems the most obvious, but it's only later in the
film, when the stone is finally turned, that we're given a (kind of) reason for
these bizarre events.
Stigma [Lawrence
Gordon Clark, 1977]:
Here, the
labourers, having returned the next day with more powerful industrial
equipment, remove the stone and discover the makeshift grave of a heavily decomposed
body. The body itself is perplexing
enough, but the appearance of several ancient daggers - four at each corner of
the grave and one embedded between the ribs of the skeleton, bellow where the victim's
heart would have been - gives the mystery an even greater depth.
Stigma [Lawrence
Gordon Clark, 1977]:
All of this
is intercut with Katherine's final struggle (which I won't spoil), creating the
impression of the two occurrences being intrinsically linked. The subsequent shot is likewise enigmatic and again
seems intended to create a potential linkage between the various elements;
tying up the narrative but really leaving the audience with as many questions
as it does legitimate answers.
In this
penultimate moment, a cloaked figure stands guard at the desecrated grave site,
somehow detached (emotionally) from previous events. As the cloaked figure peels away the layers
of an onion, I couldn't help subconsciously connecting the red of the nails and
the shape of onion itself to that of the mesmerising red orb seen earlier in
the film, but also to the iconography of the poisoned apple; the one offered by
the Evil Queen (in the guise of an aged witch) to the title character of the Walt
Disney production of Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs (1937).
Snow White
and the Seven Dwarfs [David Hand & Others, 1937]:
Stigma [Lawrence
Gordon Clark, 1977]:
If the plot
throughout Stigma is vague and muddled, moving, sometimes awkwardly, between
the domestic and the supernatural, it is moments like this that seem to create an emotional coherency beyond any
narrative ambiguity (even Clark himself admits during the accompanying DVD
introduction that he was never entirely sure where the evil in the film was
directed). In general, these moments
succeed in pushing the audience towards a certain (unspoken) interpretation
that makes even more sense following the revelation of its parting shot(s).
In this
regard, I questioned the possibility that Clark and Exton were offering us, the
viewer, the poisoned apple - drawing us into what effectively seems to be a
domestic horror movie, with the standard requirements of a woman in peril and
lashings of gore, only to reveal a subtext of persecution and atrocity that
relates back to the dark days of the witch trials (c.f. The Ash Tree) - or if
they were simply peeling away the layers of the story (like the digger, which
peeled away the layers of the earth) with the sole intention of providing us
one final jolt? The ending once again
shows the connection between the two strands of the narrative; between mother
and daughter, or between the supernatural and the psychological interpretations
of the scenes.
Although
categorised as "a ghost story", Stigma seems to be a departure from the
previous films in the series. Not least
because it's the first to feature a contemporary setting (the other films are
period pieces adapted from the work of writers like Charles Dickens and M.R.
James) but because its supernatural threat seems to take on a physical manifestation,
possessing its characters and inflicting a suffering that seems both cruel and
unusual when compared to the fate of characters in those earlier instalments. In previous Clark films, such The Stalls of
Barchester (1971) and A Warning to the Curious (1972), the characters are
punished as a result of their greed or underhandedness, or because of some
perceived failing or flaw (as in the aforementioned Lost Hearts). In Stigma, Katherine and Verity have done
nothing of real malice to incur the wrath of a vengeful spirit; their only
crime is that of a selfishness symptomatic of middle-class privilege.
